Audit director fined for breach of rotation rules

It's the first-ever penalty for audit rotation breach

Audit director fined for breach of rotation rules

News

By Mina Martin

Nicholas Benbow, director of William Buck Audit (Vic), has settled a $20,625 penalty for not adhering to audit rotation mandates, marking a precedent in ASIC’s enforcement of audit standards.

Breach of independence standards

ASIC’s action comes after identifying that Benbow contravened auditing independence standards by serving as the lead auditor for three consecutive half-year reviews of listed companies beyond the permitted five-year tenure.

ASIC Commissioner Kate O’Rourke stressed the crucial role of auditors in maintaining market integrity. This enforcement aligns with ASIC’s increased scrutiny on gatekeeper conduct announced for 2024.

“Independence is one of the cornerstones of the audit process,” O’Rourke said. “Specific audit rotation requirements were introduced 20 years ago to strengthen independence in listed company audits, and the requirements are well-known in the industry.”

See LinkedIn post here.

Not an admission of guilt

Paying the infringement notice does not imply guilt or liability on Benbow’s part but addresses ASIC’s concerns regarding audit rotation compliance.

Background and compliance

Benbow proactively disclosed the breaches to ASIC, fulfilling his obligation under section 311 of the Corporations Act. According to Regulatory Guide 187 on Auditor Rotation, auditors are expected to inform ASIC of any personal violations of the Corporations Act, which includes failing to meet the five-year audit rotation rule for listed companies.

Get the hottest and freshest mortgage news delivered right into your inbox. Subscribe now to our FREE daily newsletter.

Keep up with the latest news and events

Join our mailing list, it’s free!